love these comparisons, they really do perform surprisingly similarly. Can't wait to get my em272 mics put together, love the detail in these recordings.

They really are great microphones. I didn't apply any EQ here, but you can get the noise really low with a little reduction about 8-10khz. I have some examples of this here on Soundcloud. 

In this test I compare the self-noise of Clippy EM172 into a Sony PCM-A10 recording at extremely low gain (level 3 out of 30) versus the same microphones into a Zoom F6 recording in 32-bit float mode.

Clip 1: Sony recording of outdoor scene at original volume
Clip 2: Same Sony recording normalised (+24.2dB)
Clip 3: Zoom F6 recording of the same scene normalised to the same level
Clip 4: Sony recording of indoor scene normalised (+24.2dB)
Clip 5: Zoom F6 recording of the same scene normalised to the same level

My conclusion is that when using Clippy EM172 microphones (14dBA self noise, -28dB sensitivity), low noise preamps such as those on Zoom F series recorders or Sound Devices are overkill. In addition, if you want to avoid clipping (a reason for using 32-bit float) you can simply set the gain level on the PCM-A10 very low, and when you bring the noise levels back up there is no noise penalty (you should avoid going below level 3 however as I have demonstrated in a previous test that the noise increases considerably below level 3).

Sony PCM-A10 Low Gain Vs Zoom F6 32-Bit Float

Stereo soundscape recordings. Sometime nature, sometimes people, sometimes machinery. Sometimes quiet things like a single branch creaking in the wind on Dartmoor, sometimes odd moments in the city. Mostly local, but sometimes travelling. 

Comments

Douglas Langley

Douglas Langley

Douglas Langley

Douglas Langley

Douglas Langley

Douglas Langley

Douglas Langley

bigslug333