This podcast concerns a request for a preliminary ruling relating to the interpretation of the EU's VAT Directive, specifically regarding spa taxes collected by a German municipality. The central question is whether providing spa facilities, freely accessible to everyone, constitutes a service "for consideration" when financed by a spa tax levied on visitors. The German court seeks clarification from the Court of Justice of the European Union on whether this arrangement qualifies as a taxable economic activity under the VAT directive. Ultimately, the Court ruled that because the obligation to pay the spa tax is linked to staying in the municipality and not using the facilities, it doesn't qualify as a "supply of services for consideration." Because of that answer, the court did not need to consider a second question about geographical market and distortion of competition.

Case C-344 22 Gemeinde A (13 July 2023)

This podcast concerns an appeal to the Tax Appeals Commission regarding an income tax assessment for the 2014 tax year. The case centers on an appellant's participation in "Liberty Syndicates," which involved complex financial transactions with British Virgin Islands (BVI) companies, primarily the purchase of dividend rights. The core dispute revolves around whether these transactions constituted a genuine trade in financial instruments for tax purposes, allowing for the generation and offset of significant tax losses, or if they were investments designed primarily for tax avoidance. The Commission's decision to uphold the assessment against the appellant was heavily influenced by previous determinations in similar "Liberty appeals" (32TACD2020 and 53TACD2020), which were upheld by both the High Court and the Court of Appeal, finding that the syndicates' primary objective was tax advantage rather than profit-making trade. Furthermore, the document addresses the applicability of Section 812 of the TCA 1997 to these foreign dividends and the validity of the appellant's "expression of doubt" on their tax return, both of which were found insufficient by the Commission, consistent with prior rulings.

142TACD2025 - Income Tax

134TACD2025 - Income Tax

This podcast discusses the Tax Appeals Commission detailing an appeal regarding an income tax assessment for the 2013 tax year. The appeal concerns a taxpayer's involvement in "Liberty Syndicates," which involved complex financial transactions designed to generate tax losses through the purchase of BVI (British Virgin Islands) dividends. The Commission determined the taxpayer was not engaged in trading but rather in investment activity, and that the dividend income was taxable. Furthermore, the taxpayer's "expression of doubt" regarding their tax return was deemed invalid, ultimately upholding the Revenue Commissioners' initial assessment.

135TACD2025 - Income Tax

137TACD2025 - Income Tax

141TACD2025 - Income Tax

143TACD2025 - Income Tax

This podcast details an appeal to the Tax Appeals Commission regarding income tax assessments for 2011 and 2012, stemming from an individual's participation in Liberty Syndicates. The core of the dispute revolves around whether the appellant's involvement constituted trading in financial instruments or an investment, and the tax implications of dividend income received through complex transactions involving British Virgin Islands (BVI) companies. The commission's determination, aligning with previous rulings and court judgments, finds that the appellant was not engaged in a trade and that the transactions were designed to generate tax losses, thus upholding the original tax assessments. Furthermore, the document addresses whether expressions of doubt on tax returns were valid, ultimately finding them insufficient.

136TACD2025 - Income Tax

139TACD2025 - Income Tax

140TACD2025 - Income Tax

This podcast concerns the Tax Appeals Commission outlining an appeal concerning income tax for the 2012 tax year, specifically related to an individual's participation in Liberty Syndicates. The core issues revolve around whether the Syndicate activities constituted a taxable trade in financial instruments, whether foreign dividend income was exempt under specific tax laws, and the validity of any "expression of doubt" filed by the taxpayer. The Commission's determination upholds the original tax assessment, primarily referencing previous rulings and higher court judgments that found against similar appellants in the Liberty Syndicate appeals. The document also details the legal framework allowing the Commission to determine the appeal without a hearing, given the commonality of the issues with prior cases.

Case C-344 22 Gemeinde A (13 July 2023)

taxworld.ie

Related tracks