Meghann and Craig are joined by Brendan Dowling (Work in Progress) to discuss the 1951 Best Picture nominees.

The Oscar Should Have Gone To

1951

Variety's Clayton Davis (Awards Circuit Podcast, The Take) brings his expertise to the 1959 Best Picture race.

1959

Meghann and Craig are rejoined by Adam and Rusty Buehler to take a look at the 1958 Best Picture nominees.

1958

Meghann and Craig return to their most (?) anticipated decade yet...the 1940s! Starting with the 1949 Best Picture nominees.

1949

Meghann and Craig go back to 1947 (75 years!) to review the Best Picture nominees. Plus, Meghann has a big announcement for our listeners.

1947

Craig and Meghann are back, closer to the present day, looking at the Best Picture Nominees from a decade ago. 2012 is here!

2012

Variety's Clayton Davis joins Craig and Meghann as they reveal their Top 10 films of 2022.

Top 10 of 2022

Look who's back! Mother has arrived! Craig and Meghann return from her parental leave (like anyone gets paid) with Matty Smith to give their thoughts on the 2022 Best Picture nominees, in an episode just slightly shorter than a human's gestation period.

2022

Meghann and Craig are talking about films from the 40s again, this time, specifically, the Best Picture nominees from 1946.

1946

Meg and Craig hath returned to dive into the depths of the 1945 Best Picture contenders.

1945

Meghann and Craig continue their journey, looking back at the Best Picture Nominees of the 1944 season.

1944

Meghann and Craig are on strike! But not from 1943 or the best picture nominees of that year. Here's lookin at you, listener.

1943

This is episode is cursed. Meghann and Craig are joined by Jonah McMichael to talk about the Best Picture Nominees of 2013 and chaos ensues.

2013

Oh look, more films from the 1940s. Craig and Meghann are talking mostly war time flicks, as they decide if the Academy got the 1942 Best Picture race correct.

1942

Meghann & Craig return, talking about some forgotten films like Citizen Kane and The Maltese Falcon, as well as all time classics like One Foot in Heaven. 1941 Best Picture line up!

1941

Craig saw more new releases than ever. Meghann saw fewer than ever. Their powers combine to provide you with their Top 10 Films of 2023.

Top 10 of 2023

Top Ten of 2023

1940! What a good year for film! Meghann and Craig share their thoughts on 9 pretty good to great Best Picture nominees and also The Long Voyage Home.

1940

Craig and Meghann are joined by annual guest Matty Smith to rank this year's Best Picture nominees and decide who The Oscar Should Go To.

2023

Craig and Meghann dive into a very special miniseries, examining which Pixar films should have taken the Best Animated Oscar home. Toy Story, A Bug's Life, Toy Story 2, Monsters Inc., Finding Nemo, The Incredibles, and Cars are up first!

Pixar Part 1

Craig and Meghann are back, talking the next 7 Pixar entries and their Oscar Competition. A Rat, A Robot, A Cowboy and A Bear fly into the Oscars in a Balloon Supported House.

Pixar Part 2

Meghann and Craig welcome Rachel Lewis (Bizaardvark, The Jon and Eddie Show) to talk all things 2004 cinema, and she has a lot to say!

2004

Craig and Meghann reach way back with guest Kelly Ewing to talk about the 1992 awards crop.

1992

Meghann and Craig are joined by Joey Manderino to party like it's 1999?

1999

Meghann and Craig are joined by Matthew Scott Montgomery (So Random!, Welcome to Deadcast) to dissect the 1993 Oscar Best Picture race!

1993

Daniel Montgomery (Welcome to Deadcast, Done Disappeared) joins us, with some fava beans and a nice chianti, to discuss the 1991 Oscar films.

1991

Evan Susser (Fist Fight, Deli Boys Podcast) joins Craig and Meghann to discuss if Amadeus was the correct winner in 1984.

1984

In a two part episode, Meghan and Craig are joined by Rachel Lewis (Bizaardvark) and Matty Smith (Unikitty) to discuss the films of 2018 Oscar Race, and more. This episode touches on BlacKkKlansman, Black Panther, Bohemian Rhapsody, The Favourite and Green Book.

2018 (Part 1)

On a guestless episode, Meghann and Craig try and figure out if, and when, Glenn Close should have won her Oscar.

Glenn Close

Cait Raft (JACK AM on Twitch) is here to help us attempt to separate Art from the Artist (thanks for being a monster Woody Allen!), and talk the rest of 1977.

1977

Craig and Meghann open the new year by discussing Tom Hanks Oscar History, and deciding when he should have been nominated and when he should have won, between 1984 and 2000.

Tom Hanks (Part 1)

The Academy doesn’t always get it right. Join Meghann and Craig and special guests as they decide the rightful winners of the Oscar.

The Oscar Should Have Gone To

Popular tracks