Watch the video version HERE!: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gIDmD8NSx7g

STALKER
Andrei Tarkovsky 1979
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q3hBLv-HLEc | FULL MOVIE | Directed by An...  
_____________________________________________________
FAQ ABOUT THE VIDEO
_____________________________________________________
1. Is the “Big White Button” actually in Tarkovsky’s Stalker?
No. It’s my own thought experiment — a conceptual device that simplifies and sharpens the moral problem at the heart of Stalker. The Room in the film is ambiguous, mysterious, possibly dangerous. The Big White Button strips away that ambiguity: it gives you exactly what you truly desire, but only if that desire is genuine happiness for all, achieved through everyone’s voluntary choices. If that’s not your deepest desire… the button won’t work.
_____________________________________________________
2. Why do you present the Black Dog as female?
Because in this framework, she forms a triad with The Wife and The Child — three figures who remain behind while the men go into the Zone. They embody a kind of grounded, enduring presence that contrasts with the abstract, moral-intellectual struggle of the Zone. There’s no indication in the film about the dog’s gender, but imagining her as female enriches the symmetry — and opens a symbolic space where the Dog is not just a witness, but a watcher, a remnant, possibly a guide.
_____________________________________________________
3. What’s the role of The Black Dog in your interpretation?
She is both observer and continuity, left behind (perhaps by the alien Visitors) to see if anyone ever uses The Room — or the Button — wisely. She follows the men in the Zone but doesn’t interfere. In the end, she returns with them and appears to settle in The Stalker’s household. In my reading, she represents the quiet call to try again. She’s the cosmic “maybe.”
_____________________________________________________
4. Are you saying Tarkovsky was wrong, or incomplete?
No — more like: unfinished on purpose. Tarkovsky leaves Stalker unresolved because that’s the only honest way to end a film about moral uncertainty. What I’m offering is not a critique, but an imagined continuation — a possible next step that replaces spiritual hope with logical clarity, and then exposes the paradox at the core of that clarity.
_____________________________________________________
5. Is the White Button really possible, logically?
It seems so, at first glance. But the contradiction creeps in when you examine the conditions: happiness for all + through voluntary choices. What if some choose differently? What if someone wants suffering or domination? That’s where the thought experiment collapses into paradox. As I say in the video: “If you are God, you can make them free or happy — but not both.”
_____________________________________________________
6. So what’s the “correct” answer? Should I press the Button or not?
That’s the wrong question — and the right one. The thought experiment is designed to reveal the limits of benevolence when paired with freedom. There may be no right answer. Or rather: maybe the only right answer is to try again — knowing full well that trying again is also tragic, and human, and holy.

Tarkovsky's Black Dog and the Big White Button

Watch the video version HERE!:  https://youtu.be/cK0O7bxyJYc 

Read more about the event HERE!: 
https://www.eventbrite.com/e/talktaste-debate-should-we-be-having-more-kids-tickets-1297422067329?utm-campaign=social&utm-content=attendeeshare&utm-medium=discovery&utm-term=listing&utm-source=cp&aff=ebdsshcopyurl

https://www.instagram.com/talkandtasteclub?igsh=MXB1cmZ0ZnI4b2p3OQ%3D%3D&utm_source=qr

Learn more about The Handcock Foundation HERE!: https://www.instagram.com/thehancockfoundation/

Friday, April 25th, in New York City, I will be featured in my very first public lecture and debate event - Talk&Taste Debate: Should we be having more kids? I will of course be arguing for the position of antinatalism, and joining me, arguing for the pro-natalist position, will be the wonderful Travis Timmerman, associate professor of philosophy, and chair of the philosophy department, at Seton Hall University - and an Exploring Antinatalism Podcast alum! Check out episode #42 if you would like to see my first conversation with Travis!: 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=veplsEq3rKs

Buy his co-edited book, Exploring the Philosophy of Death and Dying HERE!: https://a.co/d/7npejM0

Doors at 7pm, and the adresss is - The Handcock Foundation, 247 Hancock Street Brooklyn, NY 11216. The admission fee, (Sorry, not my doing!) is $28.95 - Hope to see some of you there!

Talk&Taste Debate Should we be having more kids? Amanda Sukenick/Travis Timmerman LIVE in NYC 4/25!

Welcome, to episode #101 of The Exploring Antinatalism Podcast! A podcast, showcasing the wide range of perspectives & ideas throughout Antinatalism as it exists today – Welcome to the first episode of 2025! I’m your host, Amanda Sukenick, and today, I’m speaking with PhD student at the Department of Humanities at the University of Catania, and author of the new book È il nascere che non ci voleva. Storia e teoria dell’antinatalismo – Sarah Dierna!

Buy È il nascere che non ci voleva. Storia e teoria dell’antinatalismo HERE!: 
https://www.mimesisedizioni.it/libro/9791222313016
https://www.ebay.it/itm/267159195922

Follow Sarah's work HERE!: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Sarah-Dierna

Theme song by Matti Häyry! Listen to the entire song, A Real Nowhere Man by The Better Nevers, HERE!  https://youtu.be/C8aCNTUmLbE 

Matti Häyry LIVE Lecture and Performance at Puistofilosofia this summer!:
https://youtu.be/OJwrqJacX0A 
https://puistofilosofia.fi/puistofilosofia-2025/

Logo art by LifeSucks. Subscribe to him here!: https://www.youtube.com/@LifeSucks
COLORING BOOK
https://www.amazon.com/ABCs-Antinatalism-Coloring-Book-Procreation/dp/1737149109
ETSY
https://www.etsy.com/shop/LifeSucksPublishing

Help support Towarzystwo Naukowe im. Stanisława Andreskiego HERE!: 
https://tnsa.pl/
https://www.facebook.com/towarzystwo.naukowe.im.stanislawa.andreskiego
https://www.instagram.com/tnsa.pl/
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCL631KATdJw6YQsbIbXOa3Q
https://twitter.com/TNSAinfo
Voice over by: https://www.youtube.com/@WackyConundrum
https://youtu.be/c8HWz3UcaF8 

Talk&Taste Debate Should we be having more kids? Amanda Sukenick/Travis Timmerman LIVE in NYC 4/25!
Read more about the event HERE!: 
https://www.eventbrite.com/e/talktaste-debate-should-we-be-having-more-kids-tickets-1297422067329?utm-campaign=social&utm-content=attendeeshare&utm-medium=discovery&utm-term=listing&utm-source=cp&aff=ebdsshcopyurl
https://www.instagram.com/talkandtasteclub?igsh=MXB1cmZ0ZnI4b2p3OQ%3D%3D&utm_source=qr
Learn more about The Handcock Foundation HERE!: https://www.instagram.com/thehancockfoundation/

Email me at: exploringantinatalism@gmail.com

The Exploring Antinatalism Podcast #101 - Sarah Dierna

Watch the video version here!:  https://youtu.be/DyHPtux54GQ 

The Talk&Taste Debate: Should we be having more kids? event, was held in New York City, on Friday, April 25th, 2025, to a SOLD OUT audience of over 70 people, at the beautiful Hancock foundation! Arguing for the position of pro-natalism and against my antinatalism, was the wonderful Travis Timmerman, associate professor of philosophy, and chair of the philosophy department, at Seton Hall University - and an Exploring Antinatalism Podcast alum! Check out episode #42 if you would like to see my first conversation with Travis!: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=veplsEq3rKs And make sure to purchase his co-edited book, Exploring the Philosophy of Death and Dying HERE!: https://a.co/d/7npejM0 Read more about the event HERE!: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/talktaste-debate-should-we-be-having-more-kids-tickets-1297422067329?utm-campaign=social&utm-content=attendeeshare&utm-medium=discovery&utm-term=listing&utm-source=cp&aff=ebdsshcopyurl Follow Talk&Taste on Instagram, HERE! https://www.instagram.com/talkandtasteclub?igsh=MXB1cmZ0ZnI4b2p3OQ%3D%3D&utm_source=qr Learn more about The Handcock Foundation HERE!: https://www.instagram.com/thehancockfoundation/ A portion of the audio was produced by Kim Nerderveen Pieterse

Talk&Taste Debate: Should we be having more kids? Travis Timmerman vs. Amanda Sukenick, NYC 4/25/25!

The Exploring Antinatalism Podcast is the world's first podcast dedicated to the subject of Antinatalism, created by Antinatalists! Antinatalism, (Or Anti-Natalism.) Is defined by Wikipedia as, “A philosophical position and social movement that assigns a negative value to birth.” The world of Antinatalism is very vast, and though most Antinatalists do share a kernel of the same core idea, what one Antinatalist believes from the next can be wildly different. What The Exploring Antinatalism Podcast seeks to showcase,  is a wide range of the various perspectives and ideas throughout Antinatalism as it exists today, through interviews with Antinatalist thinkers and creators of all kinds. Exploring Antinatalism was originally founded in early 2020 by various members of the now extinct, Rogue Philosophy: Antinatalism Discord, but soon grew away from being a team effort, to a mostly solo project run and hosted by long time Antinatalist content producer, Amanda ‘Oldphan’ Sukenick. (Foreverwolffilms on YouTube.), with the exception of sometimes host/co-host, Mark J. Maharaj (Question Mark? on YouTube). Thank you for listening to Exploring Antinatalism!

This track is not available anymore.

Other tracks from The Exploring Antinatalism Podcast